Skip to main content

Cookie Ice Cream Sandwiches



I can't tell you how many times my girl cherub has asked for cookie ice cream sandwiches.

Oh, yes I can . . .

what I really mean is I don't want to tell you how many times I've failed at the attempt!

The first time she asked, I thought,

"Sure!  This can't be hard!"

It was for her birthday party and we were having a lot of friends and family to celebrate.

After I made the beautiful cookie ice cream sandwiches, I stuck them in the freezer.

Only to go back hours later and the ice cream had melted into a puddle on the cookie sheet

and re-froze.

Yes -- that's what happens when your freezer defrosts itself!

For that one, I had to use a spatula and cut the ice-cream into squares and scoop the re-frozen melted ice cream and the frozen cookie onto a plate.

Real fun.

That failure just made me try again.

And again I did!

Several times!

Until I finally thought,

"I will win at this!"

Here's what I did:

  • made the cookies and let them cool
  • softened the ice cream
  • scooped the ice cream, shaped to fit the cookie
  • placed shaped ice cream into freezer
  • placed cookies in an air-tight container
  • assembled just before eating
  • ENJOYED!!!!!
Cookie Ice Cream Sandwiches

even number of baked cookies (can use homemade cookies, a cookie mix, or bakery cookies)
ice cream flavor of your choice
sprinkles, if desired

Using your favorite cookie dough, make an even number of cookies, all the same size. The easiest way to do this is to use a cookie or ice cream scoop.  Of course, I made gluten free cookies and used a gluten free ice cream.  But if this isn't your need, then just use your favorite gluten-filled cookies.

Bake the cookies and allow to cool completely.

Select your favorite ice cream flavor.

Allow the ice cream to soften a bit.  Use an ice cream scoop to make ice cream balls.  Please the scooped ice cream onto wax paper and gently apply pressure to "smoosh" the ice cream into a disk that is the same size or just a wee bit smaller than the size of the cookie.

Work quickly.

Place ice cream disks on a wax paper  lined cookie sheet and place in the freezer and allow to firm up.

Just before serving, take 2 cookies and place an ice cream scoop between the two cookies.  Gently press the top and bottom cookies together to "smoosh" the ice cream just a bit.

If you desire, roll the cookie ice cream sandwich in sprinkles before serving.

Enjoy!!

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

Charleston's Style Potato Soup

Love Charleston's! Love everything I ever eat at Charleston's. Love the blackened fish sandwich, which isn't listed on the menu but you can still order it, with glazed carrots. Love the carrots! Love the chicken fingers;  the best there are!  I rarely order them -- because it's not a healthy choice, but oh boy!  They're delish! Love the honey glazed croissant. L.O.V.E! Love the pork chops with smashed potatoes and glazed carrots. Love the potato soup! Seriously adore it! It's thick. It's simple. It's delicious! We don't have a Charleston's where we live. Boo hoo! Here's a close replica of Charleston's baked potato soup.  I found it at www.tastebook.com   I made some adjustments to the recipe.  Not because I think I "know," but because I didn't have everything on hand nor can my sweet girl cherub have some of the ingredients.  I made it and didn't tell my family what it was su...

Neiman Marcus' Chicken Tortilla Soup

 I've been to eat at Neiman Marcus one time. It was really good! "Everyone" talks about the Neiman Marcus cafe and the things they love from there. Because I've only been once, my variety of selection is limited! However, I have had lunch with friends that serve this Neiman Marcus soup recipe. It is so delicious that I wanted to pass it along to you! If your weather is like our weather, one day you're making soup and the next your grilling out! But because these are simple ingredients, you'll be able to throw it together in a moments notice! Neiman Marcus' Chicken Tortilla Soup 3-4 chicken breasts; cooked and shredded (or whole chicken;  cooked & shredded) olive oil 1 c onion, chopped 1 c bell pepper, chopped 1 c celery, chopped 1 c carrots, chopped 1/2 T minced garlic 2 t cumin 2 t coriander 1 t paprika 1 t red chili powder 1 T oregano 1/2 t cayenne (adjust to your taste) 1 28-oz can diced to...

Chicken and Artichoke Casserole

Picture from Cooking with Paula Deen ( . . .and aren't those cute dishes!) We first had this delicious casserole on Mother's Day while feasting at "Dining on Persimmon Hill," which is a restaurant at the National Cowboy and Western Heritage Museum in Oklahoma City, OK.  Side note --- if you have the chance to visit the Museum, please take advantage of the opportunity.  It is a wonderful experience!  And don't forget to eat at the museum restaurant.  It's delish! So back to the casserole.  After eating it we knew we had to find out the recipe!  The owner of the restaurant graciously shared her secret!  It's a Paula Deen; which means it's full of fat AND yummy flavor! This casserole is a hit with my cherubs and the Mr.  Also, whenever I make it for friends, they always want the recipe . . . maybe they're just being nice, I'm not sure!  When you look at the recipe, you might think it's a pain, but really, it is so easy!  ...